How to Get the Best Out of a Candidate in an Interview: A Guide for Hiring Leaders
Hiring Managers

Interviews are a crucial part of the hiring process, but theireffectiveness hinges on more than just the questions you ask. To get the bestout of a candidate, you need to create an environment where they feelcomfortable, encouraged, and empowered to share their experiences and skillsauthentically. A well-conducted interview goes beyond a checklist ofqualifications and helps reveal the true potential of a candidate.

Here’s how hiring leaders can approach interviews to bring out the bestin candidates, ensuring you not only assess their qualifications but alsounderstand how they will fit and perform in your organization.

1. Set a Positive Tone from the Start

The way you begin an interview can significantly impact the candidate’sperformance. Nervousness is natural, and creating a welcoming, conversationalatmosphere can help ease initial anxiety.

How to do it:

  • Start with a friendly greeting: Introduce yourself and give a     brief overview of the interview process.
  • Create a relaxed environment: Offer a moment to settle in,     offer water or ask an easy-going icebreaker question, like how their day     has been or if they’ve had any trouble finding the office.
  • Be personable: Show your human side by sharing     something about yourself or the team. This helps build rapport and opens     the door for a more natural conversation.

Why it matters: A relaxed and comfortable candidate is more likely to give you genuine,thoughtful responses rather than overly rehearsed answers.

2. Clearly Explain the Role andExpectations

Before diving into the interview questions, ensure the candidate has aclear understanding of the role and its responsibilities. This preventsconfusion and gives the candidate the context they need to tailor theirresponses appropriately.

How to do it:

  • Provide a role overview: Briefly describe the     responsibilities, the team structure, and the company's mission. Make sure     to explain any nuances about the position that might not have been clear     from the job description.
  • Set clear expectations: Outline the skills and     attributes you're specifically looking for in this role. This helps the     candidate align their answers with what you need.

Why it matters: Candidates who fully understand the role can tailor their responses todemonstrate the most relevant experiences and skills.

3. Ask Open-Ended and BehavioralQuestions

To get the best out of a candidate, avoid simple "yes" or"no" questions. Open-ended and behavioral questions encouragecandidates to share detailed responses, showcase problem-solving abilities, andoffer insights into how they approach challenges.

How to do it:

  • Use behavioral questions: Ask candidates to describe     specific situations they've faced. For example, "Can you tell me     about a time when you had to solve a difficult problem at work?"
  • Encourage reflection: Use follow-up questions like,     "What did you learn from that experience?" or "What would     you do differently now?"
  • Explore their thinking process: Ask questions that probe how     they arrived at certain decisions or actions. For example, "What     steps did you take to resolve the issue?"

Why it matters: Behavioral questions focus on real-world examples, allowing you toassess how candidates have responded to challenges and how they apply theirskills in practice.

4. Actively Listen and Be Engaged

A successful interview is a two-way conversation, not an interrogation.By actively listening and engaging with the candidate’s responses, you createan environment of mutual respect and collaboration. This will encourage them toopen up and share more valuable insights.

How to do it:

  • Be present: Give the candidate your full     attention—avoid distractions like checking your phone or computer.
  • Show interest in their responses: Nod, ask clarifying questions,     or paraphrase their answers to ensure understanding.
  • Encourage elaboration: If a candidate gives a brief     response, ask for more details by saying, "Can you tell me more about     that?"

Why it matters: Active listening not only shows respect but also encourages thecandidate to provide deeper, more thoughtful responses, giving you a fullerpicture of their abilities and experience.

5. Tailor Questions to the Candidate’sBackground

To get the most from an interview, tailor some of your questions to thecandidate’s unique background. This helps you evaluate their fit for the rolein a more targeted way and allows them to showcase their specific strengths.

How to do it:

  • Review their resume beforehand: Make notes on key experiences or     skills you want to dig into.
  • Ask specific follow-up questions: For example, "I see you led     a project involving [X]. Can you tell me how you handled that     situation?"
  • Connect their experience to the     role: Frame questions that help them relate their past experiences to the     responsibilities of the position they’re applying for.

Why it matters: Personalized questions show that you value the candidate’s backgroundand give them the chance to highlight the most relevant aspects of theirexperience.

6. Give Candidates Time to Reflect

Sometimes, the best answers come with a bit of reflection. Allowcandidates the space to think through their responses instead of rushing them.This approach can lead to more insightful answers and demonstrates yourpatience and respect for their thought process.

How to do it:

  • Pause after asking a question: Let there be a few moments of     silence while they consider their answer.
  • Don’t interrupt prematurely: Give candidates enough time to     finish their thoughts before jumping to the next question.
  • Acknowledge complex questions: If your question requires more     thought, say, "Feel free to take a moment to think about this."

Why it matters: Allowing candidates time to reflect helps reduce pressure and can resultin more detailed, well-considered answers.

7. Encourage Questions from theCandidate

Interviews are a two-way street. Offering the candidate space to askquestions not only helps them gather the information they need to make theirdecision but also reveals what matters to them. Their questions can give youinsights into their priorities, values, and interest in the role.

How to do it:

  • Invite questions throughout the     interview: Don't wait until the end to ask if they have any questions. Prompt     them during the conversation.
  • Respond thoughtfully: Provide candid, detailed answers     to their questions, showing that you’re as invested in providing them with     the right information as they are in answering yours.

Why it matters: A candidate’s questions often reveal a lot about what’s important tothem and how well they understand the role and company.

8. Close on a Positive Note

How you close the interview is just as important as how you start. Endingon a positive, encouraging note leaves a good impression and ensures thecandidate leaves the interview feeling respected and valued.

How to do it:

  • Summarize the next steps: Briefly explain the rest of the     interview process and when they can expect to hear back from you.
  • Thank them for their time: A genuine thank you reinforces     your appreciation for their effort and interest in the role.
  • End with positivity: Say something encouraging, like,     "It was great speaking with you today," or, "You’ve shared     some really valuable insights."

Why it matters: Candidates who leave the interview with a positive impression are morelikely to be excited about the role and the company, even if they don't get theposition.

Conclusion

Getting the best out of a candidate in an interview requires more thanjust asking the right questions—it’s about creating an environment where theyfeel comfortable, engaged, and motivated to share their best selves. By settinga positive tone, tailoring your questions, actively listening, and encouragingopen conversation, you’ll not only gain deeper insights into the candidate’sabilities but also improve the overall quality of your hiring decisions.

Remember, interviews are about building a connection, assessing fit, andultimately ensuring that both you and the candidate feel confident in movingforward together.

Employers, let's get started!
Looking for employment? Start here.