Resumes are a staple of the hiring process, but they often only provide asurface-level view of a candidate. While they list qualifications, job titles,and accomplishments, they don't always capture the full potential, work ethic,or cultural fit of a person. For hiring managers, the challenge is learning howto look beyond the resume to truly assess a candidate's fit for the role andthe organization.

In this article, we will explore key strategies to help hiring managerssee past what’s on the resume and make more informed, well-rounded hiringdecisions.

1. Focus on Soft Skills and EmotionalIntelligence

A resume typically highlights technical skills and experience, but it’soften the soft skills—communication, teamwork, adaptability, andproblem-solving—that determine whether someone will succeed in the long term.Emotional intelligence (EQ) plays a major role in how an employee interactswith others, manages stress, and leads or contributes to a team.

How to Uncover Soft Skills:

• Behavioral Interview Questions: Ask questions that require     candidates to explain how they’ve handled specific situations, such as,     “Tell me about a time when you had to work under pressure” or “How do you     handle conflict within a team?”
• Scenario-Based Assessments: Create hypothetical scenarios     related to the role and ask candidates how they would approach these     situations. This reveals their thought process and interpersonal skills.
• Observe During Interviews: Pay attention to how candidates     communicate during the interview. Do they listen actively? Are they     thoughtful in their responses? These behaviors can reflect their     communication skills and emotional intelligence.

2. Assess Cultural Fit

Cultural fit is crucial for long-term success in any role. A candidatemay have the right qualifications on paper, but if they don’t align with yourorganization’s values, mission, or work environment, they might not thrive.

How to Assess Cultural Fit:

• Discuss Values and Work     Environment: Ask candidates what type of work culture they perform best in and     what values are most important to them. Compare their answers with your     company’s culture.
• Involve the Team: If possible, have candidates     meet with members of the team they will be working with. This helps you     assess how they interact with others and whether they would integrate well     into the existing team dynamics.
• Personality and Values     Assessments: Consider using personality or values-based assessments to gain a     deeper understanding of a candidate’s potential fit within the     organization.

3. Look for Growth Potential

While experience is important, hiring managers should also focus on acandidate’s potential for growth. A person who is willing to learn and has agrowth mindset may ultimately be a better fit than someone who ticks all theboxes on a resume but is less adaptable or eager to evolve.

How to Identify Growth Potential:

• Ask About Learning and     Development: Inquire about how candidates have developed new skills in previous     roles. For example, “Tell me about a time you had to learn something new     quickly” or “How do you stay current with changes in your industry?”
• Check for a History of     Progression: Even if someone’s job titles don’t seem impressive on paper, look     at whether they’ve shown steady career growth. Have they taken on new     responsibilities, moved up within their organization, or expanded their     skill set over time?
• Assess Curiosity and Innovation: Ask candidates how they approach     solving complex problems or staying curious in their field. This gives     insight into whether they have the mindset and ability to grow with your     company.

4. Look Beyond Traditional Experience

Sometimes, valuable skills and experiences come from non-traditionalbackgrounds that may not be obvious on a resume. Candidates who have worked indifferent industries, taken career breaks, or have side projects and volunteerwork often bring unique perspectives and skills.

How to Consider Non-Traditional Backgrounds:

• Explore Transferable Skills: Focus on skills that are     applicable across industries, such as project management, leadership, and     customer service. Ask how their experience in other industries or roles     has prepared them for the job at hand.
• Consider Passion Projects and     Hobbies: A candidate’s passion project, side gig, or volunteer work can     provide valuable insight into their interests, drive, and dedication. Ask     about non-work experiences that have helped them develop relevant skills.
• Be Open to Diverse Career Paths: Don’t disqualify a candidate     based solely on an unconventional career path. Some of the best hires come     from candidates with diverse, broad-ranging experiences that offer new     perspectives.

5. Test for Problem-Solving andCritical Thinking

Critical thinking and problem-solving abilities are essential for mostroles but are not always easy to discern from a resume. A candidate may haveimpressive qualifications, but can they think on their feet and navigatecomplex challenges?

How to Evaluate Problem-Solving Skills:

• Use Problem-Solving Scenarios: Ask candidates to solve a     problem or provide their thought process on a relevant challenge they     might face in the role. This helps you see how they think critically and     whether they can apply their knowledge effectively.
• Look for Examples of Initiative: Ask about times when candidates     took initiative to solve a problem or improve a process. This can reveal     their proactive nature and problem-solving mindset.
• Technical and Skills Assessments: Depending on the role, consider     giving candidates a skills assessment or real-world problem to solve as     part of the interview process.

6. Probe for Leadership andCollaboration

For leadership roles, or positions that require working withcross-functional teams, collaboration and leadership capabilities are critical.While resumes can list managerial roles, they don’t always reflect howeffectively someone can lead or work with others.

How to Evaluate Leadership and Collaboration:

• Ask About Leadership Style: For leadership roles, ask     candidates to describe their leadership style and how they motivate and     develop their team. Ask for examples of how they’ve led teams through     challenges.
• Evaluate Collaboration: Ask candidates about times     they’ve had to collaborate with others across departments or work in a     team setting. Look for examples of effective teamwork, communication, and     conflict resolution.
• Reference Checks: Speak with past colleagues or     supervisors to get a sense of the candidate’s leadership and collaboration     skills in practice.

7. Prioritize Cultural Add, Not JustCultural Fit

While cultural fit is important, also look for candidates who can add toyour culture, bringing fresh ideas and diverse perspectives. Hiring only forcultural fit can lead to homogeneity, whereas hiring for cultural add ensures amore inclusive and dynamic workplace.

How to Evaluate Cultural Add:

• Ask How They Will Contribute to     Culture: Ask candidates what they can bring to the company that is new or     different. How do they see themselves contributing to the existing culture     in a meaningful way?
• Look for Diversity of Thought and     Experience: Be open to hiring candidates who come from different backgrounds or     have different perspectives than the existing team. This helps build a     more innovative and inclusive workforce.

Conclusion

Resumes are just the starting point. While they provide usefulinformation, they often fail to capture the full picture of a candidate’spotential. Hiring managers need to see beyond the resume by focusing on softskills, cultural alignment, growth potential, and problem-solving capabilities.By using a holistic approach to hiring, you can identify candidates who willnot only succeed in the role but also stay engaged and committed to yourcompany for the long term. This deeper evaluation process helps ensure thatyour team is built on talent that is aligned with your organization’s goals,values, and future growth.

‍