When a valued employee announces their intention to leave, it can betempting to make a counteroffer in hopes of retaining them. However, while a counteroffermight seem like a quick solution to avoid the loss of talent, it’s important tocarefully evaluate whether this strategy is the best move for your business inthe long term.

In this article, we’ll explore the pros and cons of making acounteroffer, and offer guidance to help hiring managers make an informeddecision when faced with this scenario.

Pros of Making a Counteroffer

1. Retaining Valuable Talent

A key reason companies extend counteroffers is to keep high-performingemployees. If the employee’s skills, experience, and knowledge are critical tothe team or difficult to replace, retaining them can help you avoid animmediate loss of productivity. Especially in industries where talent isscarce, holding onto top performers can be crucial.

Consider This: If the employee has a specialized skill set that would take months (ormore) to replace, a counteroffer might give you time to retain expertise whilebuilding a long-term succession plan.

2. Avoiding the Costs of Turnover

Recruitment, onboarding, and training new employees are time-consumingand expensive. The cost of losing a high-performing employee can besignificant, from the time spent searching for a replacement to the learningcurve a new hire must go through before becoming fully effective.

Consider This: If the financial and operational costs of turnover are substantial, acounteroffer might seem like a cost-effective solution in the short term.

3. Sending a Message About Employee Value

When an employee hands in their resignation, offering a counteroffer canshow that the company values their contribution and is willing to invest inkeeping them on board. This can send a positive message to the employee andperhaps to the broader team.

Consider This: In situations where salary or benefits are the main reason for leaving,a counteroffer could address the immediate concern and make the employee feelmore valued.

Cons of Making a Counteroffer

1. Underlying Issues May Remain

While a counteroffer may address financial concerns, it often fails toaddress the underlying reasons why the employee wanted to leave in the firstplace. Compensation may be only part of the issue—factors like a lack of growthopportunities, poor work-life balance, or dissatisfaction with company culturemay still exist.

Consider This: If these underlying issues are not addressed, the employee may remainunhappy and could end up leaving after a few months anyway.

2. Trust and Loyalty Are Compromised

When an employee considers leaving, it’s often because they’ve mentallystarted to disconnect from the organization. Even if they accept yourcounteroffer, their long-term commitment and loyalty to the company may bediminished. They might continue exploring other opportunities, knowing theyalready considered leaving once before.

Consider This: Employees who accept counteroffers may become more disengaged or seen asa retention risk, which can impact their performance and your team’s morale.

3. Impact on Team Dynamics

If you make a counteroffer to one employee and it becomes known toothers, it could set a precedent. Other employees may start to believe thatthreatening to leave is the best way to secure a raise or promotion, which cancreate a culture of leverage rather than one based on merit.

Consider This: Counteroffers can create tension or resentment among other team members,particularly if they feel they haven’t been similarly valued or rewarded fortheir loyalty.

4. Short-Term Solution, Long-Term Risk

Studies have shown that many employees who accept counteroffers end upleaving within a year anyway. Once the initial reasons for their resignationresurface, they might feel even more dissatisfied, and by that time, you’vedelayed the inevitable.

Consider This: If the employee’s motivation for leaving is deeper than compensation,offering them a counteroffer might only delay their departure, not prevent it.You could end up in the same situation down the road, having to start therecruitment process all over again.

When to Consider a Counteroffer

While there are significant risks, there are scenarios where making acounteroffer may be the right choice:

• Financial is the Only Concern: If the employee is leaving     purely for a higher salary elsewhere, and your company can offer a     competitive counteroffer that aligns with market rates, this might be a     simple fix.
• High-Impact Employees: When the employee is a key     contributor with specialized skills that are critical to ongoing projects     or operations, offering a counteroffer could be necessary to avoid     immediate disruption.
• No Significant Underlying Issues: If the employee has generally     been happy and productive but is drawn to an external offer for short-term     reasons, such as relocation or a one-time opportunity, a counteroffer may     keep them engaged without lingering dissatisfaction.

When a Counteroffer May Not Be a GoodIdea

In many cases, extending a counteroffer is not the best long-termstrategy, especially in the following situations:

• Underlying Issues Exist: If the employee has voiced     concerns about their role, management, or the company culture, offering     more money will not resolve these deeper issues.
• Lack of Engagement or Commitment: If the employee has already     started mentally checking out, offering a counteroffer may only result in     them staying for the wrong reasons—like a temporary pay increase—while     their long-term commitment remains compromised.
• Potential Impact on Company     Culture: If making a counteroffer would create division or unhealthy     competition among your team, it might do more harm than good in the long     run.

Alternatives to Counteroffers

Rather than waiting for an employee to resign before making them acounteroffer, consider these proactive strategies to improve retention:

• Conduct Stay Interviews: Regularly check in with     employees about their job satisfaction, career goals, and any concerns     they may have. This helps you address issues before they lead to a     resignation.
• Career Development Opportunities: Make sure your employees have     clear pathways for growth and are continually challenged in their roles.     Offering training, promotions, or new responsibilities can help keep top     talent engaged.
• Competitive Compensation     Packages: Regularly review compensation and benefits to ensure they are     competitive within your industry. This can help prevent employees from     feeling the need to seek better offers elsewhere.

Conclusion

Making a counteroffer to retain an employee can sometimes be the rightmove, but it is not without risk. While counteroffers can provide short-termsolutions, they often fail to address the deeper reasons for dissatisfactionand can lead to long-term challenges in trust and engagement. Hiring managersmust carefully weigh the pros and cons before extending a counteroffer, andwhere possible, focus on proactive retention strategies that address employeeneeds before they consider leaving.

Ultimately, the decision to make a counteroffer should be based on athorough understanding of the employee’s reasons for leaving, the company’sability to meet their needs, and the long-term impact on both the team and theorganization.

‍